What Happens Next Will Scare You

Melissa LaMartina

Rachel Silver

Kendra North

Officer Rebecca Harrington (segment "Police Dash Cam Captures Bigfoot!")

Leanna Chamish

911 Operator (segment "Funeral Home Invasion 911 Call") (voice)

George Stover

Charles Goyer (segment "From The Shadows: Meet Scraps")

Chris LaMartina

Randy (segment "Lake Zaca Monster") (voice)

Rachel D. Wilson

Myra

Kalima Young

June

Kathy Carson

Vanessa

Troy Jennings

Lester

Johnny Marra

Eugene Wiley

Mike C. Walls

Mr. Tickles

John Bennett

Chuck

Evangeline Ridgaway

Rose Silver

Caitlin Rife

Clickbait Zombie

Cash K. Allen

Viral Video Son

Wes Allen

Viral Video Dad

Greg Bowen

Sasquatch

Erin Reid

Monster Vera

Sadie Roussell

Ginny Wainwright (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

Tracey Allyn

Mrs. Wainwright (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

Daemon McConnaughey

Greg Wainwright (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party") (voice)

Mark Burchick

Birthday Party Extra #1 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

Katharine Vary

Boy's Mom (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")

Richard Donahue

Birthday Party Extra #2 (segment "Ghost Ruins Birthday Party")