Straight Shooter

Tim McCoy

"Lightning" Bill Carson

Ben Corbett

Magpie

Ted Adams

Brainard

Forrest Taylor

Henchman Luke Green

Budd Buster

Sheriff Ed Long

Stephen Chase

Saloon Patron (archive footage)

Jack Ingram

(uncredited)

Jack 'Tiny' Lipson

Saloon Waiter (archive footage)

George Morrell

Ben Martin

Bob Terry

Saloon Gunman Jim (archive footage)

Julie Sheldon

Margaret Martin

Reed Howes

Henchman Slade

Carl Mathews

Henchman Lane

Hal Carey

Singer (archive footage)

Donald Gallaher

Saloon Gunman (archive footage)

Sherry Tansey

Saloon Gunman (archive footage)

Wally West

Deputy Ned