Pony Soldier

Tyrone Power

Constable Duncan MacDonald

Cameron Mitchell

Konah

Thomas Gomez

Natayo Smith

Penny Edwards

Emerald Neeley

Robert Horton

Jess Calhoun

Adeline De Walt Reynolds

White Moon (as Adeline DeWalt Reynolds)

Howard Petrie

Insp. Frazer

Stuart Randall

Standing Bear

Earl Holliman

Undetermined Secondary Role (uncredited)

Anthony Earl Numkena

Comes Running (as Anthony Earl Numkena)