The Night We Should've Left Behind

Logan Morris

Amelia

Maisey Crawford

Taylor

Annabelle Perkins

Victoria

Dylan "Twinkle" Mervine

Marco The Cashier

Brooke Wagner

The Librarian

Connor Hearn

Walters

Olivia Zercher

Cop #1

Sophia Wolpert

Cop #2

Addy Barrett

Henchman #1

Haley Yashinski

Henchman #2

Angel R. Reed

Additional Voices

May Serle

911 Dispacher

Emily Stefany

Grocery Store Cashier

Violet Hearn

Coffee Shop Customer #1

Wren Heckman

Coffee Shop Customer #2

Keith Hearn

Missing Boy In Photo

April Feagley

Missing Girl In Photo