You Were My First Boyfriend

Cecilia Aldarondo

Self

Ella Fraley

Sarah

Натали Грэйс

Self - Cecilia's Schoolmate

Melissa Baker

Self

Sarah Baker Butterfield

Self

Laura Gallegos

Self

Gabriel Kristal

Self

Joel Pickering

Self

Jo Anne Taylor

Self

Trinity Soos

Hannah Whipple

Xander Black

Maya Karp

Delanie Nicole Gill

Lindsey

Erica Kaylee Gouldthorpe

Isabella Rivera-Gandulla

Cole Donaldson