Santastein

Kaylie Heyner

Mikayla

Lilli Rose Rittner

Young Paige

Jared Korotkin

Max Causey

Ophelia Rivera

Paige Byers

Michael Vitovich

Santastein

Damien Edwards

Edgar

Heather Fisch

Katie

Fernando Morales

Austin

Leo Pereira

Peter

Claire Veater

Grandma Byers

Maisy Kay

Jenny

Rafa Llama

Diego

Alejandro Sevilla

Stan

Stanley Ross

Chief Dougherty

Mauricio Bermudez

Officer Bermudez

Brad Kaaya

Officer Bradley

Brian Long

Paige's Dad

Caro Gramajo

Paige's Mom

Byron Duncan

Conspiracy Theory Joe

Jeff Clarke

Santa Claus

Fletcher Hammond

Young Max

Victoria Camilion

Vicky

Jeff Peterson

Mr. Newhams

Brooke Hall

Patricia